2021 All-Pioneer Athletic Conference Baseball Teams
FIRST TEAM
Liberty Division
| Position | Name | Grade | School |
| P | Trey Yesavage | 12 | Boyertown |
| P | Andrew McGowan | 11 | Perkiomen Valley |
| C | Jake Stasyk | 12 | Perkiomen Valley |
| IF | Cole Hertzler | 12 | Boyertown |
| IF | Aydan McNelly | 11 | Spring-Ford |
| IF | Michael Tinneny | 12 | Perkiomen Valley |
| IF | Ethan Sabatino | 11 | Owen J. Roberts |
| OF | Nolan McCloskey | 11 | Methacton |
| OF | James Kisela | 12 | Spring-Ford |
| OF | Dylan Ducharme | 12 | Spring-Ford |
| DH | Billy Bean | 12 | Spring-Ford |
Frontier Division
| Position | Name | Grade | School |
| P | Jason Bilotti | 12 | Phoenixville |
| P | Steven Rinda | 12 | Pottsgrove |
| C | Cooper Fiore | 12 | Pottsgrove |
| IF | Brad Zielinski | 11 | Upper Merion |
| IF | Ian Ferrero | 10 | Upper Perkiomen |
| IF | Michael Memmo | 12 | Phoenixville |
| IF | Brendan Kenning | 10 | Pope John Paul II |
| OF | Yasir Gardner-Sizer | 11 | Pottsgrove |
| OF | John Ryan McMenamin | 11 | Pottsgrove |
| OF | Michael Sharadin | 10 | Upper Perkiomen |
| DH | Avery Spencer | 12 | Pottsgrove |
SECOND TEAM
Liberty Division
| Position | Name | Grade | School |
| P | Graham Halfpenny | 11 | Methacton |
| P | Michael Cunningham | 12 | Spring-Ford |
| C | Cole Casamento | 12 | Spring-Ford |
| IF | Jake Books | 11 | Spring-Ford |
| IF | Dean Mihos | 11 | Owen J. Roberts |
| IF | Griffin Straface | 11 | Spring-Ford |
| IF | Ethan Martin | 12 | Boyertown |
| OF | Sam Morris | 12 | Owen J. Roberts |
| OF | Dominic Miceli | 12 | Perkiomen Valley |
| OF | Brandon Shane | 11 | Boyertown |
| DH | Ethan Ferraro | 12 | Perkiomen Valley |
Frontier Division
| Position | Name | Grade | School |
| P | Kade Breisblatt | 12 | Phoenixville |
| P | Drew Kingsbury | 11 | Phoenixville |
| C | Justin Geiger | 12 | Phoenixville |
| IF | Gavin Feulner | 9 | Pope John Paul II |
| IF | Nick Freese | 10 | Pottsgrove |
| IF | Nick Hutchinson | 11 | Upper Merion |
| IF | Caleb Quiles | 12 | Pottstown |
| OF | Malachi Duka | 12 | Upper Perkiomen |
| OF | Oscar Brenes | 10 | Upper Merion |
| OF | Wes Barker | 12 | Upper Perkiomen |
| DH | Devlin Kranich | 10 | Upper Perkiomen |
