| First | Last | Team | Attempts | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zack | Pierce | St. Pius X | 482 | 2001 |
| Mike | Bach | Spring-Ford | 390 | 1996 |
| Zack | Pierce | St. Pius X | 362 | 2000 |
| Matt | Lucas | Owen J. Roberts | 360 | 1998 |
| Ryan | Brumfield | Owen J. Roberts | 354 | 2009 |
| Joe | Haley | Spring-Ford | 346 | 1994 |
| Ralph | O’Neil | Spring-Ford | 342 | 1992 |
| Ryan | Brumfield | Owen J. Roberts | 340 | 2008 |
| Rahsul | Faison | Pottsgrove | 321 | 2017 |
| Ed | Augustin | Spring-Ford | 319 | 1989 |
| Ryan | Brumfield | Owen J. Roberts | 319 | 2010 |
| Wyatt | Scott | Owen J. Roberts | 311 | 2013 |
| Cody | Richmond | Boyertown | 302 | 2013 |
| Rahsul | Faison | Pottsgrove | 281 | 2016 |
| Isaiah | Taylor | Pottsgrove | 256 | 2018 |
| Matt | Garcia | Phoenixville | 255 | 2016 |
| Avrey | Grimm | Owen J. Roberts | 250 | 2021 |
| Boyd | Skarbek | Pope John Paul II | 239 | 2023 |
| Isaiah | Taylor | Pottsgrove | 231 | 2019 |
| Wyatt | Scott | Owen J. Roberts | 227 | 2012 |
| Aidan | Schaffer | Upper Perkiomen | 222 | 2013 |
